Wednesday, March 27, 2019

Week 11.2 D'avella - Ecologies of Investment

How do different materialities and ecologies play/ed a role in Argentina's economic crisis discussed in this article?

9 comments:

  1. Different materials and ecologies played a role in how Argentines handled the economy and money before and after their many crises. After a crisis Argentines began navigating a newfound ecology of the ties and interdependence between different forms of currency such as American dollars, australs, pesos, gold and bonex bonds. During the crises Argentines faced devaluation of their currency they turned to pesos, a more stable currency, in which they bought dollars and converted them into pesos as needed. After the 2001 crises Argentines moved towards “mattressism” in which they collected many forms of currency and hid them in lock boxes in their freezers, walls, ceilings and even buried them in their yards in fear of the next economic crises as well as in distrust of the banks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In Argentina there was more than just Dollars and Pesos, like bricks of currency for example, are intertwined to make up the ecologies. Everything is connected in familiarity not just economically. After the crash the people had to find new ways to rise and rebuild their ecologies.The different materialities gave way to a new kind or type of trading. The different options gave people different angles to use and try.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In this article author Nicholas D'avella speaks on ecology and how the citezens of Argentina would use different methods of ecology to save their money during the country's financial crisis. The author speaks about a women named Mariela who had experienced first hand of the crisis and her steps towards saving her money after the 2001 crisis. Ever since the crisis Mariela does not trust any bank (understandable) and keeps all of her currency in a saftey deposit box. Mariela, like many citezens of argentina, started to keep different forms of currency like gold, pesos, bonds, and american dollars for the reason that the currency in argentina would lose value. This ecology would be used by many of Argentinian citezens and treated as an investment. One investment would not be treated the same as another

    ReplyDelete
  4. Argentina's intense financial crisis is interwoven into the relationships between different types of currency. The current system, started after the financial crisis of 2001, is known as "colchonismo", a very literally translated word that means storing diverse types of material money in hidden places around their home. The money kept varies in type, but typically includes USD, Argentine pesos, and even gold. Keeping different forms of currency allows Argentines to stay ahead of the constant back and forth value of different materials and currencies. This system is combined with the push to invest in real estate, most specifically apartments. Unlike the real estate market of the US, apartment buying is generally done in cash and without formalities like borrowing or really any bank interaction. This gives people security in investing in something physical outside of bank control. Both of these systems, combined with traditional banking, have allowed Argentines to form their own systems outside of the crisis-ridden traditional economy while still acting as players in it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The different materialities and ecologies that played roles in the Argentine economic crisis caused a number of different outcomes among the Argentine community. Some of the most notable being that of the constant changes in the national currency and reoccurring rates of inflation. Interestingly, the article notes that someone could put 10000 dollars worth of Argentine currency under their mattress in 1975, only to pull it back out in 2009 with it being worth .00000027 cents. With the inflation and constantly changing worth of currency, the ecology of Argentine investments has changed and varied over the years. It's become popular for many Argentine citizens to invest in and save different international currencies to eventually exchange it with their own, yielding a greater reward. The Argentine governments introduction of various different currencies put an ecological stress on its own citizens, causing them to find ways to adapt and evolve over time to survive in their suffering economy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In response to extreme inflation in their country's economy, Argentinians used a variety of different currencies — such as gold, pesos, and bonds — after the financial crisis because they did not trust banks to keep their money safe. This collection of currencies also usually included USD, which was then used to participate in the housing market to buy and sell apartments. Since the housing market in Argentina uses mostly cash for transactions, this assisted Argentinian citizens in creating their own economy separate from the national economy.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In Argentina, the intense, inconsistent inflation rates, along with the frequent change in the value of their currency caused a response from the Argentinians to gain more security in their finances. Due to the changing of currency rates, Argentines would use a variety of more stable currencies, such as U.S dollars, pesos, gold, Australia, etc. and would switch back and forth as needed. This allows citizens to have more power and control when dealing with their own money. After the crisis of 2001, there was large distrust in the banks. This started a system that is still used in ARgentina called “colchonismo” which is where Argentinians gathered different types of currency and then would hide it in several different places around the home for safe-keeping. After such struggle and uncertainty dealing with the economy, Argentinians have been able to to adapt and be able to survive through these systems they’ve created.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In the wake of a crisis, Argentinians found that their own currencies were becoming badly inflated. This led to Argentinians attempting to turn to new forms of currencies that were seen as less unpredictable, such as dollars, pesos, or even gold. Distrust of banks and fear of further economic crises ruled the behavior of Argentinians, who turned to lives of "mattressism," meaning that they took currencies and attempted to hide them in places around their house to avoid them falling victim to a fluctuating market. This distrust of the bank systems led to the citizens of Argentina essentially forming their own economy.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Argentine narrative practice contribute to the development to an ecological trust refined to histories directed to building promising futures. Argentina’s economic past shows how the value of currency can be misguiding, producing surreality in money surrounding Argentina that extends to the present. They produced and navigated a rich ecology of relations between diverse monetary forms. Argentines have constituted complex math that mixes bonds, currencies, and international price index into their daily economic lives. Some Argentine’s in the era of neoliberal restructuring (1991-2002) who had an unfavorable exchange rate to national industry enjoyed ten years of monetary stablitiy. In the mid 1990’s, Argentina had no control over monetary policy and could only cover fiscal expenditures by accepting foreign loans rather than building the monetary base or making trade more competitive through devaluation, which are important tools usually at a state’s disposal. Also, international lenders demanded structural adjustment policies in exchange for the loans that made convertablity possible caused economic problems. The government had difficulty obtaining sufficient foreign currency reserves
    to distinguish between its “payment obligations to foreign lenders and its conversion obligations to local savers” (pg. 181) By late 1990’s, neoliberal economics advocated further cuts to public spending and more privatizations, such policies were politically untenable, with a large population without work.
    Having money in the bank and having money in cash were two different material manifestations of what was the same ‘below average’ value system, the dollar. Each form of saving was divided by a ‘sharp circulatory asymmetry’; people moved and changed their cash,while their deposits were stuck in the bank. Thus, banks formed a part of a monetary ecology that gave problems for small savers, who saw money circulating in unfavourable ways to most argentinians.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.